Search neutrality

« Back to Glossary Index

Background and Definition of Search Neutrality
– Search neutrality was mentioned in an academic paper by Andrew Odlyzko in March 2009.
– The term gained public attention after an opinion letter by Adam Raff in December 2009.
– Adam and Shivaun Raff launched to promote investigations against Google.
– The concept of search neutrality lacks consensus compared to net neutrality.
– Search engines are designed to collect, filter, and rank results based on relevance, making neutrality difficult to define and implement.

Vertical Search Spam Penalties
– Users rely on search engines to access information on the web.
– Foundem, a vertical search service, experienced a significant drop in traffic and business.
– Foundem claimed that Google deliberately applied penalties to vertical search engines as competition.
– The use of iframe HTML tags and javascript loading were cited as potential reasons for the penalties.
– Foundem is supported by the Initiative for Competitive Online Marketplace, a Microsoft proxy group.

Other Cases and Investigations
Google’s dominant market share has made it a target for search neutrality litigation.
– Other companies, such as and Microsoft’s Ciao!, joined Foundem in claiming unfair penalties by Google.
Google expressed concern for fair competition in a blog article in February 2010.
– Antitrust laws have been used to investigate search neutrality allegations against Google.
– The FTC ended its antitrust investigation into Google without filing a formal complaint.

Arguments for and against Search Neutrality
Arguments for Search Neutrality:
– Results would not be biased towards sites with more advertising, but towards sites most relevant to the user.
– Encourages sites to have more quality content rather than pay to rank higher on organic results.
– Restrains search engines from only supporting their best advertisers.
– Allows for organized, logical manipulation of search results by an objective, automatic algorithm.
– Personalized search results might suppress information that disagrees with users’ worldviews, isolating them in their own cultural or ideological filter bubbles.

Arguments against Search Neutrality:
– Forcing search engines to treat all websites equally would remove the biased view of the Internet that search users are seeking.
– Search neutrality could cause search engines to become stagnant and limit their ability to adjust rankings based on popularity, relevance, or quality content.
– Requiring transparent algorithms could expose search engines’ private intellectual property and allow spammers to exploit and target the algorithm.
– Removing a search engine’s ability to directly manipulate rankings limits their ability to penalize dishonest websites that use black hat techniques.
– Search engines like Google and Bing have different levels of bias, with Google being less biased than its principal competitor.

Impact of Search Neutrality on Websites
Google’s Universal Search system has been criticized for using the least neutral search engine practices, leading to a decline in web traffic for external websites.
– Search neutrality could potentially affect the ranking of websites and their visibility on search engine results pages (SERPs).
– The case against Google brought by the owners of Foundem highlights the impact of search neutrality on website rankings.
– Search engines’ ability to directly manipulate rankings can influence the success or failure of websites.
– Search neutrality could limit search engines’ ability to link to their own services, potentially affecting web traffic for external websites.

Search neutrality (Wikipedia)

Search neutrality is a principle that search engines should have no editorial policies other than that their results be comprehensive, impartial and based solely on relevance. This means that when a user types in a search engine query, the engine should return the most relevant results found in the provider's domain (those sites which the engine has knowledge of), without manipulating the order of the results (except to rank them by relevance), excluding results, or in any other way manipulating the results to a certain bias.

Search neutrality is related to network neutrality in that they both aim to keep any one organization from limiting or altering a user's access to services on the Internet. Search neutrality aims to keep the organic search results (results returned because of their relevance to the search terms, as opposed to results sponsored by advertising) of a search engine free from any manipulation, while network neutrality aims to keep those who provide and govern access to the Internet from limiting the availability of resources to access any given content.

« Back to Glossary Index

Submit your RFP

We can't wait to read about your project. Use the form below to submit your RFP!

Gabrielle Buff
Gabrielle Buff

Just left us a 5 star review

Great customer service and was able to walk us through the various options available to us in a way that made sense. Would definitely recommend!

Stoute Web Solutions has been a valuable resource for our business. Their attention to detail, expertise, and willingness to help at a moment's notice make them an essential support system for us.

Paul and the team are very professional, courteous, and efficient. They always respond immediately even to my minute concerns. Also, their SEO consultation is superb. These are good people!

Paul Stoute & his team are top notch! You will not find a more honest, hard working group whose focus is the success of your business. If you’re ready to work with the best to create the best for your business, go Stoute Web Solutions; you’ll definitely be glad you did!

Wonderful people that understand our needs and make it happen!

Paul is the absolute best! Always there with solutions in high pressure situations. A steady hand; always there when needed; I would recommend Paul to anyone!

Vince Fogliani

The team over at Stoute web solutions set my business up with a fantastic new website, could not be happier

Steve Sacre

If You are looking for Website design & creativity look no further. Paul & his team are the epitome of excellence.Don't take my word just refer to my website ""that Stoute Web Solutions created.This should convince anyone that You have finally found Your perfect fit

Jamie Hill

Paul and the team at Stoute Web are amazing. They are super fast to answer questions. Super easy to work with, and knows their stuff. 10,000 stars.

Paul and the team from Stoute Web solutions are awesome to work with. They're super intuitive on what best suits your needs and the end product is even better. We will be using them exclusively for our web design and hosting.

Dean Eardley

Beautifully functional websites from professional, knowledgeable team.

Along with hosting most of my url's Paul's business has helped me with website development, graphic design and even a really cool back end database app! I highly recommend him as your 360 solution to making your business more visible in today's social media driven marketplace.

I hate dealing with domain/site hosts. After terrible service for over a decade from Dreamhost, I was desperate to find a new one. I was lucky enough to win...

Paul Stoute has been extremely helpful in helping me choose the best package to suite my needs. Any time I had a technical issue he was there to help me through it. Superb customer service at a great value. I would recommend his services to anyone that wants a hassle free and quality experience for their website needs.

Paul is the BEST! I am a current customer and happy to say he has never let me down. Always responds quickly and if he cant fix the issue right away, if available, he provides you a temporary work around while researching the correct fix! Thanks for being an honest and great company!!

Paul Stoute is absolutely wonderful. Paul always responds to my calls and emails right away. He is truly the backbone of my business. From my fantastic website to popping right up on Google when people search for me and designing my business cards, Paul has been there every step of the way. I would recommend this company to anyone.

I can't say enough great things about Green Tie Hosting. Paul was wonderful in helping me get my website up and running quickly. I have stayed with Green...